Home › Opinion › Letters to the Editor
Unhappy with court decisions
STORY TOOLS
Share and Enjoy
More Letters to the Editor
Rate this Article
In my experience, the Anderson Small Claims Court is biased in favor of businesses, no matter how wrong the business is. On three occasions, with three different businesses — a car dealer, a heating and air conditioning company and a landscaping service — I went to small claims court and lost.
My car was leaking power steering fluid and I told them to be sure and check the hose. They said I needed something else. They did the work ($700) and a few days later, the car still leaking, they determined it to be the hose. The judge ruled I should be refunded the money for the part I did need, but not for the part I didn’t need.
I had a 10-year warranty on parts and labor for our heat pump ($4,500) and had problems after a year’s time. The new owner (a relative of the first) would not honor the warranty. I pointed out in court that this company still had the same name, same location, same telephone number, even the same ad in the paper. The judge ruled that this company did not have to honor my warranty.
A landscaper assured me he could clear up several bald spots in the yard. We bought the materials he recommended and he did the work. Between my sprinkler system and the rain, the yard got plenty of water. After six weeks, not one blade of grass. He promised to give me $100 of my money back, but never did. I asked the court for a partial refund of $400 but despite all the pictures I showed the judge on how my yard looked after six weeks, he ruled for the defendant.
Johnnie Phelps, Anderson
Comments
There are 2 responses to this article.
Comments are meant to offer our readers a forum for thoughtful, robust debate about local issues.
Comments are moderated, but you may find the content of the conversations offensive, objectionable or factually disputable.


IndependentMail.com does not necessarily condone the comments here, nor does it review every post or respond to every suggestion for a comment to be removed.
Before you post, consider this:
Please read our official user-contributions policy.
They will stand before THE JUDGE one day and answer for what they did. Judges are picked from Attorneys, they learn how to do all they can and protect themselves, and stick together like thieves. Most of them have a bad attitude before they even listen to what anyone's problem is, they all should be on TV so everybody has the option to see, and someone with more authority over seeing them, making sure they are treating people right.
in response to The_Shark
Don't even think about trying Family Court. You lose the car, air conditioner, and pay the landscaper for the remaining years of your life.
Judges and Lawyers....hey what else needs to be said.
Rest assured the Judges in Family Court take care of the female. I'm not saying all men are great but there is a few rotten apples in the female gender as well. A Judge sees himself as "GOD", responsible to no one here on this earth. Many a men are broken by the Family Court system, mental & financial.
(Requires free registration.)