Login | Site Map | Archives | Electronic Edition | Mobile Edition | Alerts | RSS | Contact Us | Submit News & Photos | Subscriber Services

HomeSportsUSC Sports

Why argue over which conference is best?

STORY TOOLS

There’s an ever-growing debate going on nationwide, and it has nothing to do with McCain vs. Obama or Congress vs. bailout.

And trust me, it’s not nearly as important.

For some reason, the fans, the media and ESPN (who I refuse to include with “media”) are asking the same old pointless question: Which conference is the best in college football?

Last year it was all about the Pac-10 and SEC. This year the debate again centers on the SEC, but it’s matched up with the talented Big 12. When it comes down to it, they’re both loaded.

No. 2 Alabama and No. 3 LSU are undefeated and look exceptional on defense. Despite losses last week, No. 11 Georgia and No. 12 Florida have a showdown in November of monumental proportions. And the other teams aren’t bad either, with No. 13 Auburn and No. 19 Vanderbilt having a chance to move up in the polls.

The Big 12 is all about quarterbacks this year. It boasts the likes of No. 1 Oklahoma’s Sam Bradford, No. 4 Missouri’s Chase Daniel, No. 5 Texas’ Colt McCoy and No. 7 Texas Tech’s Graham Harrell. It’s hard to find a more exciting and talented mix than that.

So, why does it matter which is the best?

We debate the BCS because it decides the national champion and is as flawed as our current financial system. Heisman Trophy candidates are argued because it’s left up to a bunch of voters who turn it into a high school popularity contest.

But conference bragging rights are just that. There’s no real trophy like that Stanley Cup that all the members from the SEC can pass around when more teams finish in the top 10 than the Big 12. We all know there is no sort of playoff or round-robin tournament.

And please, no more fan polls. You can’t watch a single game on any of the ESPN family of networks without one. I don’t need some stupid demographic telling us that folks in the state of Oklahoma think the Big 12 is the best. I took geography in the ninth grade. I know where the Sooner State is.

Basically it’s all propaganda. The media and ESPN believe hyping conferences, not teams, will bring in more traffic to their outlets. And sadly, it probably does.

But, the only time conference debates mean anything is during bowl season. It’s fun to keep up with how the Big 12 does against the SEC because teams are actually playing each other. Right now, Missouri’s schedule doesn’t have LSU or Georgia on it.

So, if you want to call me up and discuss who’s the best in the SEC West between LSU and the Tide, I’m all ears. But if you want to argue the status of two completely different conferences with entirely diverse recruiting patterns and playing styles, I’m out.

There are just more important issues at hand.

Comments

There are no comments yet.

Comments are meant to offer our readers a forum for thoughtful, robust debate about local issues.

Comments are moderated, but you may find the content of the conversations offensive, objectionable or factually disputable.

Click here for our user-contributions policy.

Comments

IndependentMail.com does not necessarily condone the comments here, nor does it review every post or respond to every suggestion for a comment to be removed.

Before you post, consider this:

  1. Keep it clean. Comments containing obscene, profane, vulgar, lewd or sexually-oriented language -- including creative spelling and typographical representations of foul language -- will be removed.
  2. Be truthful. Don't lie or spread rumors about anyone or anything. Stick to discussing what is factually known.
  3. Be nice. Don't threaten anyone, and do not post any comments that involve racism, sexism or any other sort of -ism that degrades another person. Hateful or offensive comments will not be tolerated.
  4. Police yourselves. Hit the "Suggest Removal" button to alert us to objectionable comments. Do not respond to trolls or those who seek to harass another poster.
  5. Stay focused. Keep on the story's topic.
  6. Help us get it right. If you have information to add to the story or you find a factual error or misspelling send us an email or call the newsroom at 864-260-1274.

Please read our official user-contributions policy.



Post a comment
(Requires free registration.)

Username:

Password:
(Forgotten your password?)

Comment:

  Want the editors to know how you feel? Click here to say it privately.

Please download the latest version of Adobe Flash Player, or enable JavaScript for your browser to view the video player.