Login | Site Map | Archives | Electronic Edition | Mobile Edition | Alerts | RSS | Contact Us | Submit News & Photos | Subscriber Services

HomeColumnsSports Columns

NFL ref faces the music

STORY TOOLS

No apology by NFL referee Ed Hochuli is good enough for fans of the San Diego Chargers, not if a blown call in last Sunday’s loss to the Denver Broncos ends up costing Norv Turner’s team a spot in the playoffs.

If that happens, Hochuli will be to San Diego supporters what Steve Bartman is to Cubs fans.

Yet, like our old buddy Rocky Balboa once said, “It ain’t how hard you hit — it’s how hard you can get hit and keep moving forward.”

Hochuli knew he made a mistake immediately after ruling a Jay Cutler fumble was actually an incomplete pass. If the call is correct, the ball goes to the Chargers and they win.

Instead he blew the whistle prematurely, negating a change of possession and giving the ball back to the Broncos at the spot of the “fumble” that wasn’t.

Naturally every jerk in the world had to fire off an e-mail to Hochuli, (it’s amazing how anonymity makes folks so bold) many of a threatening nature.

What did Hochuli do?

He answered them. He apologized. He admitted he made a terrible error. In fact, he said, “I failed miserably.”

In reality the NFL is at fault for providing a safety net for a quarterback when such a play occurs. Under league rules once the whistle blows the play cannot be reviewed in the booth, which is absurd.

So yes, Hochuli screwed up, but the NFL Rules Committee screwed up worse.

Still, this official — who has worn stripes for a quarter of a century and worn them well — offered no alibis for his error. He could’ve ignored the criticism and gone into hiding, but he didn’t.

He was and is a man.

Based on news reports the tide has turned somewhat. The e-mails are still coming, but now they’re a bit more sympathetic. Mistakes are made at workplaces every day, seven days a week, 365 days a year.

Most of them, however, don’t happen on national television and in front of 70,000 screaming fans.

Again, this hardly makes the Chargers feel better. Victory was in their grasp when Cutler lost his grasp on the football, but the record book reads Denver 39, San Diego 38, and that score will stand forever.

But Ed Hocholi is an honorable man, and to define his career by one unfortunate call is to dismiss a body of work that has helped make him one of the best officials in the National Football League.

Whether the mistake will cost him a spot working the NFL playoffs has yet to be determined. It shouldn’t. Instead, it should make the league revisit its application of rules involving quarterbacks and whistles.

The bottom line is that we all make mistakes. And facing those mistakes head on — as Hochuli did — proves he has a lot more guts and character than all those hateful, anonymous e-mailers combined.

Comments

There is 1 response to this article.

Comments are meant to offer our readers a forum for thoughtful, robust debate about local issues.

Comments are moderated, but you may find the content of the conversations offensive, objectionable or factually disputable.

Click here for our user-contributions policy.

Comments

IndependentMail.com does not necessarily condone the comments here, nor does it review every post or respond to every suggestion for a comment to be removed.

Before you post, consider this:

  1. Keep it clean. Comments containing obscene, profane, vulgar, lewd or sexually-oriented language -- including creative spelling and typographical representations of foul language -- will be removed.
  2. Be truthful. Don't lie or spread rumors about anyone or anything. Stick to discussing what is factually known.
  3. Be nice. Don't threaten anyone, and do not post any comments that involve racism, sexism or any other sort of -ism that degrades another person. Hateful or offensive comments will not be tolerated.
  4. Police yourselves. Hit the "Suggest Removal" button to alert us to objectionable comments. Do not respond to trolls or those who seek to harass another poster.
  5. Stay focused. Keep on the story's topic.
  6. Help us get it right. If you have information to add to the story or you find a factual error or misspelling send us an email or call the newsroom at 864-260-1274.

Please read our official user-contributions policy.

I think you nailed it with this statement, "In reality the NFL is at fault for providing a safety net for a quarterback when such a play occurs."

It seems that over the years, the quarterback has become the "sacred cow," and cannot be touched. My opinion is that if they have made it to this level of play, they should be able to take the hits. If he had not blown the whistle and Cutler had been hit or injured, he would have been crucified for that.

Pretty soon the rules are going to get even more sissified for the QB, that they will be wearing flags and you have to grab the flag instead of tackling.




Post a comment
(Requires free registration.)

Username:

Password:
(Forgotten your password?)

Comment:

  Want the editors to know how you feel? Click here to say it privately.

Please download the latest version of Adobe Flash Player, or enable JavaScript for your browser to view the video player.